ABA Banking Journal
No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Ag Banking
    • Commercial Lending
    • Community Banking
    • Compliance and Risk
    • Cybersecurity
    • Economy
    • Human Resources
    • Insurance
    • Legal
    • Mortgage
    • Mutual Funds
    • Payments
    • Policy
    • Retail and Marketing
    • Tax and Accounting
    • Technology
    • Wealth Management
  • Newsbytes
  • Podcasts
  • Magazine
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise
    • Magazine Archive
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Podcast Archive
    • Sponsored Content Archive
SUBSCRIBE
ABA Banking Journal
  • Topics
    • Ag Banking
    • Commercial Lending
    • Community Banking
    • Compliance and Risk
    • Cybersecurity
    • Economy
    • Human Resources
    • Insurance
    • Legal
    • Mortgage
    • Mutual Funds
    • Payments
    • Policy
    • Retail and Marketing
    • Tax and Accounting
    • Technology
    • Wealth Management
  • Newsbytes
  • Podcasts
  • Magazine
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise
    • Magazine Archive
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Podcast Archive
    • Sponsored Content Archive
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Home Uncategorized

Fifth Circuit stays Judge Pittman’s order transferring case to Washington D.C.

A Fifth Circuit panel issued an order staying Judge Mark Pittman’s transfer order until Tuesday, June 18, 2024.

June 3, 2024
Reading Time: 3 mins read
Fifth Circuit stays Judge Pittman’s order transferring case to Washington D.C.

LATE FEE LITIGATION
U.S. Chamber of Commerce v. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
Date: May 28, 2024

Issue: Whether the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s (CFPB) late fee final rule exceeds its statutory authority under the Credit Card Accountability Responsibility and Disclosure Act (CARD)  Act and violates the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) and Truth in Lending Act (TILA).

Case Summary: A Fifth Circuit panel (Judges Catharina Haynes, Don Willett, and Stuart Duncan) issued an order staying Judge Mark Pittman’s transfer order until Tuesday, June 18, 2024, at 4:00 p.m. EDT.

As background, under the CARD Act, issuers may charge a “penalty fee” for violating a cardholder agreement, if the fee is “reasonable and proportional to such omission or violation.” In assessing whether a penalty fee is “reasonable and proportional,” the CFPB must consider issuer costs, cardholder deterrence, and cardholder conduct. In the final rule, the CFPB reduced the late fee safe harbor to $8.

In its complaint, the American Bankers Association argued the final rule violates: the U.S. Constitution’s Appropriations Clause, the CARD Act, the Dodd-Frank Act, and the Truth in Lending Act’s effective-date provision. ABA also argued the final rule is arbitrary and capricious under the APA. ABA moved the court for a preliminary injunction.

On May 10, 2024, Judge Pittman granted a preliminary injunction determining ABA showed a substantial likelihood of success on the merits of its constitutional claim tied to the CFPB’s funding.  In Community Financial, the Fifth Circuit ruled the CFPB’s funding structure was unconstitutional because Congress’ decision to cede its appropriations power to the bureau violates the U.S. Constitution’s structural separation of powers. Applying Community Financial, Judge Pittman concluded the late fee rule is likely unconstitutional.  Next, Judge Pittman determined the final rule imposed a substantial threat of irreparable harm to ABA’s members, and granting an injunction would serve the public interest.

On May 28, 2024, the CFPB filed a renewed motion to transfer the case to Washington, D.C. The CFPB argued court congestion, local interests, and familiarity with governing law favored a transfer. On the same day, Judge Pittman granted CFPB’s motion, transferring the case to Washington, D.C. Judge Pittman reasoned the practical factors making a trial more expeditious and inexpensive favored a transfer. He also concluded four public-interest factors favored a stay: the administrative difficulties flowing from court congestion; the local interest in having localized interests decided at home; the familiarity of the forum with the law governing the case; and the avoidance of unnecessary problems of conflict of laws or in the application of foreign law.

In response, ABA filed an emergency petition for a writ of mandamus and administrative stay, asking the Fifth Circuit to order the Fort Worth district court to reopen the case. ABA argued the district court abused its discretion in concluding court congestion favored a transfer to the District of Columbia. ABA cited the Fifth Circuit’s decision in In re Clarke, which ruled court congestion alone is not a sufficient basis for transfer, because it undermines “weight” due to a plaintiff’s choice and ignores the plaintiffs’ role as master of the complaint. ABA also claimed the district court erred in concluding local interests favored the transfer, as non-party citizens in the Northern District of Texas have a strong interest in the case’s outcome.

ABA also claimed the district court abused its discretion in concluding one of the private factors — practicalities of litigation — favored the transfer. According to Judge Pittman, the number of attorneys in the case traveling to Fort Worth at their client’s or the government’s expense justified the transfer. But ABA stressed the location of counsel should not factor into the “practicalities of litigation” analysis or outweigh ABA’s selection of venue. In light of the public and private interest factors errors, ABA stressed the CFPB did not establish good cause for the transfer.

On May 29, 2024, the Fifth Circuit stayed the transfer order until 4:00 p.m. EDT on June 18. The Fifth Circuit also ordered the CFPB to respond to ABA’s mandamus petition by June 6.

Bottom Line: The preliminary injunction remains in place despite the transfer order.

Documents: Opinion, Order, Petition

Tags: Banking Docket
ShareTweetPin

Related Posts

Supreme Court upholds government authority to dismiss False Claims Act cases

Eighth Circuit affirms vacatur of Regulation II

Uncategorized
November 3, 2026

While the Eighth Circuit vacated Reg. II, the Sixth Circuit has yet to issue its decision in Linney’s Pizza. There, a Kentucky federal court granted summary judgment to the Fed and rejected the merchant’s challenge to Reg. II.

U.S. Supreme Court vacates Ninth Circuit preemption decision

U.S. Supreme Court to review discovery ruling in DOGE FOIA lawsuit

Uncategorized
November 3, 2026

The U.S. Supreme Court agreed to review a D.C. Circuit ruling allowing discovery to determine whether the U.S. DOGE Service qualifies as an agency subject to the Freedom of Information Act.

Minnesota dismisses cash-sweep program lawsuit against U.S. Bancorp

Southern District of New York rules Merrill Lynch but not BofA must face cash sweep lawsuit

Uncategorized
November 3, 2026

A New York federal court dismissed a class action against Bank of America Corporation, Bank of America N.A. and Managed Account Advisors LLC but allowed claims against Merrill Lynch to proceed in a lawsuit alleging unreasonably low interest...

Former CFPB enforcement attorneys file class action challenging Unlock’s home equity agreements

Former CFPB enforcement attorneys file class action challenging Unlock’s home equity agreements

Uncategorized
November 3, 2026

Colorado homeowner Sheila Johnsen filed a class action against Unlock Partnership Solutions alleging that they disguised mortgage loans as home equity agreements to evade lending laws, charge excessive interest and impose unfair contract terms.

New York district court denies Terraform Labs’ motion to dismiss, declines to follow Ripple ruling

Northern District of California dismisses cryptocurrency fraud lawsuit against banks, Stanford Federal Credit Union

Uncategorized
November 3, 2026

A California federal court dismissed a lawsuit alleging that several financial institutions helped carry out a $570,000 cryptocurrency scam, ruling that an anonymous married couple failed to state valid claims for aiding and abetting fraud and unauthorized wire...

Florida federal court denies motion to dismiss shareholder derivative lawsuit

Florida federal court denies motion to dismiss shareholder derivative lawsuit

Uncategorized
November 3, 2026

A Florida federal court refused to dismiss a lawsuit alleging that bank directors breached their fiduciary duties by changing corporate bylaws to protect their positions and prevent shareholders from removing them.

NEWSBYTES

FinCEN severs MEXC crypto exchange from U.S. financial system

November 6, 2026

Owen, Bowman discuss bank technology adoption, fighting fraud

November 6, 2026

Fed: Consumer credit increased 4.2% in Q3

November 6, 2026

SPONSORED CONTENT

Banking Technology at a Strategic Crossroads

Banking Technology at a Strategic Crossroads

October 29, 2026
The Shift from Demographic Marketing

The Shift from Demographic Marketing

October 1, 2026
Meeting Ag Lending Goals Without Going It Alone

Meeting Ag Lending Goals Without Going It Alone

October 1, 2026
Beyond the Portfolio: The Wealth Manager’s New Role in a Multigenerational World

Beyond the Portfolio: The Wealth Manager’s New Role in a Multigenerational World

September 17, 2026

PODCASTS

Podcast: Proactively managing the core provider relationship

October 22, 2026

Podcast: How community banks can keep farmers farming in turbulent times

October 14, 2026

Podcast: The birth of American money and how it triggered a revolution

October 8, 2026

American Bankers Association
1333 New Hampshire Ave NW
Washington, DC 20036
1-800-BANKERS (800-226-5377)
www.aba.com
About ABA
Privacy Policy
Contact ABA

ABA Banking Journal
About ABA Banking Journal
Media Kit
Advertising
Subscribe

© 2026 American Bankers Association. All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Ag Banking
    • Commercial Lending
    • Community Banking
    • Compliance and Risk
    • Cybersecurity
    • Economy
    • Human Resources
    • Insurance
    • Legal
    • Mortgage
    • Mutual Funds
    • Payments
    • Policy
    • Retail and Marketing
    • Tax and Accounting
    • Technology
    • Wealth Management
  • Newsbytes
  • Podcasts
  • Magazine
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise
    • Magazine Archive
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Podcast Archive
    • Sponsored Content Archive

© 2026 American Bankers Association. All rights reserved.