ABA Banking Journal
No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Ag Banking
    • Commercial Lending
    • Community Banking
    • Compliance and Risk
    • Cybersecurity
    • Economy
    • Human Resources
    • Insurance
    • Legal
    • Mortgage
    • Mutual Funds
    • Payments
    • Policy
    • Retail and Marketing
    • Tax and Accounting
    • Technology
    • Wealth Management
  • Newsbytes
  • Podcasts
  • Magazine
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise
    • Magazine Archive
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Podcast Archive
    • Sponsored Content Archive
SUBSCRIBE
ABA Banking Journal
  • Topics
    • Ag Banking
    • Commercial Lending
    • Community Banking
    • Compliance and Risk
    • Cybersecurity
    • Economy
    • Human Resources
    • Insurance
    • Legal
    • Mortgage
    • Mutual Funds
    • Payments
    • Policy
    • Retail and Marketing
    • Tax and Accounting
    • Technology
    • Wealth Management
  • Newsbytes
  • Podcasts
  • Magazine
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise
    • Magazine Archive
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Podcast Archive
    • Sponsored Content Archive
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT
Home ABA Banking Journal

A Push-Pull Fight Over Fintech Charters

October 15, 2019
Reading Time: 3 mins read
A Push-Pull Fight Over Fintech Charters

Endpapers from one of Hugh Lofting's "Dr. Dolittle" books depicting the pushmi-pullyu.

By Dawn Causey, Thomas Pinder and Andrew Doersam

Remember Dr. Dolittle? He was a vet who could talk to animals. One of the rarest was the “pushmi-pullyu,” a llama with two heads at opposite ends of its body. The pushmi-pullyu experienced great frustration when it tried to move because each head wanted to trot the creature off in a different direction. Most of the time they got along fine, but occasionally their wills clashed, and the result was stalemate.

In some ways, the mythical “pushmi-pullyu” reminds us of the “dual banking” battle between the OCC and the New York State Department of Financial Services over the agency’s special-purpose national bank charter, sometimes called the “fintech charter.” In Vullo v. OCC, Judge Victor Marrero ruled that OCC lacks authority under the National Bank Act’s “business of banking” provision to offer a fintech charter.

In 2016, OCC investigated the possibility of a fintech charter for non-depository fintech firms, but NYDFS filed a lawsuit to challenge the proposal. However, OCC was successful in its motion to dismiss when the court determined that the claims were not ripe for review. The clash continued last July, when OCC announced that it would begin accepting applications for fintech charters, and NYDFS again sued.

Like the struggle of the pushmi-pullyu, OCC and NYDFS each want to trot fintech off in different directions. On one head, NYDFS claimed that OCC’s decision to grant fintech charters upsets the balance of the dual banking system because it intrudes into New York’s home turf. NYDFS complained that New York citizens will suffer by losing “critical financial protections” that New York banking law and regulatory oversight currently provides. NYDFS also claimed it will suffer direct economic harm, because its operating expenses are funded by assessments levied on New York State licensed institutions. On the other head, OCC proposed a fintech charter to address the rapid technological changes taking place in the financial services industry so that federal banking system can remain vibrant and relevant.

OCC again filed a motion to dismiss, asserting that NYDFS lacked standing, the dispute was unripe and time-barred, and NYDFS failed to state a claim for relief under the Administrative Procedure Act. But this time, Judge Marrero denied OCC’s motion. The ruling permits NYDFS to proceed with its claims that the fintech charter exceeds the OCC’s authority under the NBA.

After praising to the dual banking system, the court ruled that the term “business of banking,” as used in the NBA, “unambiguously requires receiving deposits as an aspect of the business.” The OCC argued that the term “business of banking” was ambiguous and a reasonable interpretation would provide the OCC with chartering authority for nonbanks that do not accept deposits. However, according to the court, the fintech charter would enable a “dramatic disruption of federal-state relationships.” As a result, the court held that only depository institutions are eligible to receive national bank charters from the OCC.

Additionally, the court explained that because New York already provides a comprehensive regulatory system for nearly 600 non-depository fintech companies, those regulations “are all at risk of becoming null and void” by the fintech charter. The court noted that fintech firms may leave New York altogether, which will force NYDFS to incur costs now to avoid such harm. As a result, the court found that NYDFS established standing to pursue its statutory and constitutional challenges against the OCC.

But not all was lost for OCC. The court dismissed NYDFS’ Tenth Amendment claim. The court found that NYDFS’ claim did not trigger the Tenth Amendment because it related only to whether Congress had clearly chosen to preempt state chartering authority, rather than whether Congress had exceeded its enumerated powers.

The legal battle simmering in New York is the latest iteration of the pushmi-pullyu battle of wills in the dual banking system.

Dawn Causey is general counsel at ABA, where Thomas Pinder is deputy general counsel and Andrew Doersam is a paralegal.

ADVERTISEMENT
Tags: FintechNational Bank Act
ShareTweetPin

Related Posts

BIS drafts guidance for central banks on AI adoption

BIS releases report on connections between banks and nonbanks

Compliance and Risk
July 11, 2025

Differences between regulations for banks and those for nonbank financial intermediaries may have created incentives to shift business activities to the NBFI sector, so bank supervisors should apply “close scrutiny” to such interactions, according to the report.

ABA Regulatory Policy and Compliance Inbox: Must banks disclose all co-branding relationships?

ABA Regulatory Policy and Compliance Inbox: Just what is reportable under CRA?

Compliance and Risk
July 9, 2025

What about refinances and renewals for small business, small farm and community development loans? And: Understanding risk-based pricing notices.

The ever-expanding role of chief risk officer

The ever-expanding role of chief risk officer

Human Resources
July 7, 2025

'A new era has emerged in which CROs faced greater nonfinancial risk amid pressure to boost the bottom line.'

Using Artificial Intelligence to Make Sense of Mountains of Data

Three myths about AI in banking

Technology
July 3, 2025

Common myths and misperceptions might confuse about what to expect and misdirect investment and efforts.

Banking forward: What is top of mind for 2025? 

ABA survey: Most banks likely to stick with current core provider

Newsbytes
July 2, 2025

While 69% of bankers are "extremely" or "somewhat likely" to remain with their current core provider at the next renewal, when they do pursue core conversions, the primary reason is poor customer service, according to ABA's survey results.

Chair’s View: Celebrating a century of giving back

Chair’s View: Celebrating a century of giving back

Community Banking
July 1, 2025

Not only do we celebrate the 150th anniversary of our organization, we also commemorate an important milestone for the ABA Foundation.

NEWSBYTES

ABA, associations seek clarity about Fannie, Freddie credit scoring change

July 11, 2025

ABA DataBank: Copper prices rise on tariff announcement

July 11, 2025

FDIC issues regulatory relief guidance for Texas

July 11, 2025

SPONSORED CONTENT

Navigating Disruption in Ag Lending – Why Tariffs Are Just the Tip of the Iceberg

Navigating Disruption in Ag Lending – Why Tariffs Are Just the Tip of the Iceberg

July 1, 2025
AI Compliance and Regulation: What Financial Institutions Need to Know

Unlocking Deposit Growth: How Financial Institutions Can Activate Data for Precision Cross-Sell

June 1, 2025
Choosing the Right Account Opening Platform: 10 Key Considerations for Long-Term Success

Choosing the Right Account Opening Platform: 10 Key Considerations for Long-Term Success

April 25, 2025
Outsourcing: Getting to Go/No-Go

Outsourcing: Getting to Go/No-Go

April 5, 2025

PODCASTS

Breaking down the bank-related provisions in the big budget bill

July 10, 2025

Podcast: Inside ABA’s new Treasury Check Verification System API

June 25, 2025

Podcast: Staying close to clients amid tariff-driven volatility

June 18, 2025
ADVERTISEMENT

American Bankers Association
1333 New Hampshire Ave NW
Washington, DC 20036
1-800-BANKERS (800-226-5377)
www.aba.com
About ABA
Privacy Policy
Contact ABA

ABA Banking Journal
About ABA Banking Journal
Media Kit
Advertising
Subscribe

© 2025 American Bankers Association. All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Ag Banking
    • Commercial Lending
    • Community Banking
    • Compliance and Risk
    • Cybersecurity
    • Economy
    • Human Resources
    • Insurance
    • Legal
    • Mortgage
    • Mutual Funds
    • Payments
    • Policy
    • Retail and Marketing
    • Tax and Accounting
    • Technology
    • Wealth Management
  • Newsbytes
  • Podcasts
  • Magazine
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise
    • Magazine Archive
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Podcast Archive
    • Sponsored Content Archive

© 2025 American Bankers Association. All rights reserved.