ABA Banking Journal
No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Ag Banking
    • Commercial Lending
    • Community Banking
    • Compliance and Risk
    • Cybersecurity
    • Economy
    • Human Resources
    • Insurance
    • Legal
    • Mortgage
    • Mutual Funds
    • Payments
    • Policy
    • Retail and Marketing
    • Tax and Accounting
    • Technology
    • Wealth Management
  • Newsbytes
  • Podcasts
  • Magazine
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise
    • Magazine Archive
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Podcast Archive
    • Sponsored Content Archive
SUBSCRIBE
ABA Banking Journal
  • Topics
    • Ag Banking
    • Commercial Lending
    • Community Banking
    • Compliance and Risk
    • Cybersecurity
    • Economy
    • Human Resources
    • Insurance
    • Legal
    • Mortgage
    • Mutual Funds
    • Payments
    • Policy
    • Retail and Marketing
    • Tax and Accounting
    • Technology
    • Wealth Management
  • Newsbytes
  • Podcasts
  • Magazine
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise
    • Magazine Archive
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Podcast Archive
    • Sponsored Content Archive
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Home Legal

Looking Beyond the CFPB’s Constitutionality Question

June 24, 2016
Reading Time: 2 mins read

By Dawn Causey, Thomas Pinder and Andrew Doersam

When considering the ongoing case of PHH Corp. v. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, the adage that “one should not lose sight of the forest for the trees” comes to mind. The hysteria in the headlines recently has focused on the often-discussed issue of the constitutionality of the CFPB’s structure. But looking beyond the headlines, this case has wider implications on when and how the CFPB exercises its enforcement powers.

The banking industry is hoping the D.C. Circuit will declare the CFPB’s structure unconstitutional. This result, while appealing, is unlikely and ignores other important issues that may have lasting effects on the industry.

In June 2015, CFPB Director Richard Cordray overruled an administrative law judge’s recommendation for a $6.5 million fine against mortgage lender PHH for allegedly requiring unlawful kickbacks from mortgage insurers in violation of RESPA Section 8. Cordray demanded that PHH pay 18 times more—or $109 million—for each time it accepted a kickback on or after July 21, 2008.

Although RESPA sets a three-year statute of limitations, Cordray determined that it did not apply to the agency’s administrative proceedings, but only in federal district court actions. In oral argument, Judge A. Raymond Randolph appeared concerned with this determination. He explained that even if the statute was silent, the court has historically borrowed a statute of limitations from another state or federal statute. However, if the D.C. Circuit upholds the CFPB’s view, it could open the door for the agency to bring even more penalties against companies for past conduct.

In a notable shift away from guidance issued by the Department of Housing and Urban Development, Cordray found that RESPA Section 8(c)(2) does not exempt payments that are tied in any way to a referral. PHH argued that its captive mortgage reinsurance agreements were exempt under Section 8(c)(2) because they were “bona fide” payments for services actually performed. What is troubling about Cordray’s decision is that he pulled the plug on HUD’s interpretation of RESPA, which has been trusted by an entire industry for two decades.

PHH argued that the CFPB’s new interpretation of Section 8(c)(2) deprived it of due process by retroactively imposing a new statutory interpretation in an administrative proceeding. Traditionally, the government communicates its statutory interpretations by issuing a proposed rule, seeking comment and then issuing a final rule. Instead, Cordray applied his new interpretation of RESPA to punish PHH for conduct that was approved by HUD.

Not only did Cordray punish PHH without fair notice through his new interpretation of RESPA Section 8, he then increased PHH’s fine eighteen-fold. Such an exponential expansion by the CFPB should have be applied only after the industry was given fair notice of the new interpretation. To retroactively apply a penalty for previously legal behavior goes well beyond statutory and regulatory norms. As Judge Brett Kavanaugh explained in oral argument, a policeman could not tell an individual that it was okay to cross a street and then immediately give the person a ticket upon reaching the other side.

Although the constitutional issue of the CFPB’s structure will get the most notice in the headlines, the industry cannot afford to overlook these other issues at stake in this case.

Dawn Causey is general counsel at ABA, where Thomas Pinder is SVP for litigation and Andrew Doersam is a paralegal.

Tags: RESPA
ShareTweetPin

Related Posts

Supreme Court overturns legal test for deferring to agency interpretations

Supreme Court declines to consider crypto firm lawsuit for master account access

Legal
November 16, 2026

The U.S. Supreme Court has declined to hear the appeal of a cryptocurrency firm that sued the Federal Reserve after the central bank denied it a master account.

CFPB issues decision on TILA preemption of state laws

CFPB seeks dismissal of lawsuit over changes to fair lending enforcement

Compliance and Risk
November 13, 2026

The CFPB is asking a federal court to dismiss a lawsuit brought by consumer groups and vendors to prevent the agency from removing disparate impact as a prohibited practice from Regulation B, which implements the Equal Credit Opportunity...

National bank preemption and the integrity of the U.S. payments system

ABA comments on merchant groups’ lawsuits against OCC, NCUA

Legal
November 12, 2026

“We’re disappointed but not surprised by the merchants' lawsuits, which seek only to undermine the nation's trusted and tested payments system,” ABA and its co-plaintiffs said.

Trade groups urge California to delay passage of GHG emissions reporting bill

Court partially rolls back California climate reporting laws

Compliance and Risk
November 10, 2026

A federal appeals court has narrowed the scope of a pair of California laws that require companies, including financial institutions, to report greenhouse gas emissions and climate risks.

District court vacates Labor Department position on rollover advice

Democratic attorneys general sue FinCEN over beneficial ownership reporting

Compliance and Risk
October 28, 2026

A coalition of 21 Democratic state attorneys general has filed a lawsuit to reverse the Trump administration’s decision to scale back the scope of beneficial ownership information reporting requirements.

Federal appeals court strikes down the Fed’s debit card fee cap

Federal appeals court strikes down the Fed’s debit card fee cap

Legal
October 26, 2026

Court says the Fed must rewrite the rule capping how much banks can charge for processing debit card transactions. ABA called the decision disappointing,

NEWSBYTES

NCUA eases ‘common bond’ membership requirements for federal credit unions

November 16, 2026

Warsh: Fed studying possible economic ramifications of AI

November 16, 2026

Supreme Court declines to consider crypto firm lawsuit for master account access

November 16, 2026

SPONSORED CONTENT

AI Is Changing the Rules of Banking Competition

AI Is Changing the Rules of Banking Competition

November 13, 2026
Banking Technology at a Strategic Crossroads

Banking Technology at a Strategic Crossroads

October 29, 2026
The Shift from Demographic Marketing

The Shift from Demographic Marketing

October 1, 2026
Meeting Ag Lending Goals Without Going It Alone

Meeting Ag Lending Goals Without Going It Alone

October 1, 2026

PODCASTS

Podcast: Cathy Owen on the road ahead for America’s banks

November 11, 2026

Podcast: Proactively managing the core provider relationship

October 22, 2026

Podcast: How community banks can keep farmers farming in turbulent times

October 14, 2026

American Bankers Association
1333 New Hampshire Ave NW
Washington, DC 20036
1-800-BANKERS (800-226-5377)
www.aba.com
About ABA
Privacy Policy
Contact ABA

ABA Banking Journal
About ABA Banking Journal
Media Kit
Advertising
Subscribe

© 2026 American Bankers Association. All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Ag Banking
    • Commercial Lending
    • Community Banking
    • Compliance and Risk
    • Cybersecurity
    • Economy
    • Human Resources
    • Insurance
    • Legal
    • Mortgage
    • Mutual Funds
    • Payments
    • Policy
    • Retail and Marketing
    • Tax and Accounting
    • Technology
    • Wealth Management
  • Newsbytes
  • Podcasts
  • Magazine
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise
    • Magazine Archive
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Podcast Archive
    • Sponsored Content Archive

© 2026 American Bankers Association. All rights reserved.