ABA Banking Journal
No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Ag Banking
    • Commercial Lending
    • Community Banking
    • Compliance and Risk
    • Cybersecurity
    • Economy
    • Human Resources
    • Insurance
    • Legal
    • Mortgage
    • Mutual Funds
    • Payments
    • Policy
    • Retail and Marketing
    • Tax and Accounting
    • Technology
    • Wealth Management
  • Newsbytes
  • Podcasts
  • Magazine
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise
    • Magazine Archive
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Podcast Archive
    • Sponsored Content Archive
SUBSCRIBE
ABA Banking Journal
  • Topics
    • Ag Banking
    • Commercial Lending
    • Community Banking
    • Compliance and Risk
    • Cybersecurity
    • Economy
    • Human Resources
    • Insurance
    • Legal
    • Mortgage
    • Mutual Funds
    • Payments
    • Policy
    • Retail and Marketing
    • Tax and Accounting
    • Technology
    • Wealth Management
  • Newsbytes
  • Podcasts
  • Magazine
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise
    • Magazine Archive
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Podcast Archive
    • Sponsored Content Archive
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT
Home Uncategorized

Seventh Circuit rules proof of causation is required to recover in FCA actions.

August 1, 2023
Reading Time: 2 mins read
Seventh Circuit rules proof of causation is required to recover in FCA actions.

False Claims Act
Calderon v. Carrington Mortgage Services LLC
Date: June 14, 2023

Issue: Whether relators must show proof that false statements were the proximate cause of any eventual default to recover under the False Claims Act (FCA).

‌Case Summary:  In a 3-0 decision, a Seventh Circuit panel ruled an FCA relator alleging false certifications for FHA insurance coverage must prove the false statement caused or increased the risk of a subsequent default.

Relator Michelle Calderon alleged Carrington Mortgage Services made false statements to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). According to Calderon, Carrington’s statements misrepresented borrowers’ risk levels when submitting applications to have loans covered by federal mortgage insurance. Federal mortgage insurance from the Federal Housing Administration (FHA) allows those considered too risky to apply for traditional mortgage by covering the losses for lenders if the borrower defaulted on the loan. Calderon claimed Carrington provided false information or omitted certain information, which would have made HUD consider these loans too risky or ineligible for federal mortgage insurance. Calderon sued alleging Carrington violated the FCA.

The district court granted summary judgment for Carrington. The court determined Calderon could not prove the alleged misrepresentations caused a monetary loss. The court emphasized a plaintiff must show actual and proximate cause to recover under the FCA. The court explained Calderon must show Carrington’s statements “played some role in causing or increasing the risk of subsequent default.” Calderon appealed the district court’s decision.

On appeal, the Seventh Circuit affirmed. Calderon attempted to show Carrington’s statements caused a default by presenting statistical analysis and loan-by-loan analysis. However, the court determined this information did not show a causal link to default. According to the panel, Carrington’s false certification to HUD “must not only be material, they also must cause a foreseeable harm: a type that a reasonable person would see as a likely result of his or her conduct.” The panel explained to show proximate causation, Calderon needed to put forward evidence suggesting the false certifications in the reviewed loans were the foreseeable cause of the later defaults. The panel relied on the Fight Circuit’s reasoning in United States v. Miller, and the Third Circuit’s reasoning in United States v. Hibbs, which made explicit statements about the need to prove what caused the defaults to recover.

Calderon argued she should be allowed to extrapolate causation from a generalized statistical analysis of Carrington’s federally insured loans. Carrington contended Calderon had to proceed loan by loan through the 349 loans and show how each allegedly false statement caused each loan’s default. The panel did not resolve which method was appropriate. The panel found Calderon did not meet her burden under either method.

Bottom Line: The decision clarifies the high bar for relators to prove proximate causation in FCA suits. FCA relators must develop evidence concerning the reason for default on loans for which they assert their claims.

Documents: Opinion

ADVERTISEMENT
Tags: Banking Docket
ShareTweetPin

Related Posts

Recent news from Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control: April 5

Recent news from Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control: June 9

Uncategorized
June 9, 2025

News items that are the most recent sanctions-related actions from the Office of Foreign Assets Control.

Preliminary injunction denied in bid to delay Capital One’s Discover purchase

Preliminary injunction denied in bid to delay Capital One’s Discover purchase

Uncategorized
June 2, 2025

A California federal court denied a group of consumers’ motion for a preliminary injunction seeking to delay Capital One’s impending purchase of Discover.

Third Circuit reverses FCRA lawsuit against Nissan over lease dispute

Third Circuit reverses FCRA lawsuit against Nissan over lease dispute

Uncategorized
June 2, 2025

A unanimous Third Circuit panel reversed a New Jersey federal court decision and ruled that a jury could find Nissan’s credit reporting inaccurate and its investigation unreasonable under the FCRA.

Green Dot agrees to pay Federal Reserve $44 Million to resolve UDAP allegations.

ABA, co-plaintiffs file joint motion with Federal Reserve to stay proceedings in stress test lawsuit

Uncategorized
June 2, 2025

ABA and its co-plaintiffs filed a joint motion with the Fed to stay proceedings in their lawsuit claiming the Fed’s stress testing framework violates the APA.

U.S. Supreme Court vacates Ninth Circuit preemption decision

U.S. Supreme Court clarifies wire fraud liability

Uncategorized
June 2, 2025

In a unanimous decision, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled a defendant may be convicted of federal fraud for inducing a victim to enter into a transaction under materially false pretenses, even if the defendant did not intend to...

Eleventh Circuit revives cash advance fraud lawsuit against Citigroup

Eleventh Circuit revives cash advance fraud lawsuit against Citigroup

Uncategorized
June 2, 2025

In a unanimous decision, an Eleventh Circuit panel reversed and remanded a district court’s dismissal of a lawsuit alleging Citigroup operated a cash advance fraud scheme.

NEWSBYTES

In 90th anniversary year, Stonier graduates 182

June 12, 2025

ABA, CBA support maintaining confidentiality of CFPB nonbank risk determinations

June 12, 2025

Survey finds high customer satisfaction with banking apps

June 12, 2025

SPONSORED CONTENT

AI Compliance and Regulation: What Financial Institutions Need to Know

Unlocking Deposit Growth: How Financial Institutions Can Activate Data for Precision Cross-Sell

June 1, 2025
Choosing the Right Account Opening Platform: 10 Key Considerations for Long-Term Success

Choosing the Right Account Opening Platform: 10 Key Considerations for Long-Term Success

April 25, 2025
Outsourcing: Getting to Go/No-Go

Outsourcing: Getting to Go/No-Go

April 5, 2025
Six Payments Trends Driving the Future of Transactions

Six Payments Trends Driving the Future of Transactions

March 15, 2025

PODCASTS

Podcast: Old National’s Jim Ryan on the things that really matter

June 12, 2025

Podcast: What bankers need to know about ‘First Amendment audits’

June 5, 2025

Podcast: Accelerating banking for quick-service restaurants

May 8, 2025
ADVERTISEMENT

American Bankers Association
1333 New Hampshire Ave NW
Washington, DC 20036
1-800-BANKERS (800-226-5377)
www.aba.com
About ABA
Privacy Policy
Contact ABA

ABA Banking Journal
About ABA Banking Journal
Media Kit
Advertising
Subscribe

© 2025 American Bankers Association. All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Topics
    • Ag Banking
    • Commercial Lending
    • Community Banking
    • Compliance and Risk
    • Cybersecurity
    • Economy
    • Human Resources
    • Insurance
    • Legal
    • Mortgage
    • Mutual Funds
    • Payments
    • Policy
    • Retail and Marketing
    • Tax and Accounting
    • Technology
    • Wealth Management
  • Newsbytes
  • Podcasts
  • Magazine
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise
    • Magazine Archive
    • Newsletter Archive
    • Podcast Archive
    • Sponsored Content Archive

© 2025 American Bankers Association. All rights reserved.