Federal and state regulators should work together to modernize the regulatory treatment of capital for mutual institutions, with a recent Federal Reserve proposal providing a “strong template” for coordination, the American Bankers Association and Independent Community Bankers of America said today.
In a joint letter to regulators, ABA and ICBA note that mutual institutions do not have the same access to external equity capital as stock institutions. Instead, they generally rely heavily on retained earnings to build capital, “which can constrain their ability to respond to unexpected losses, support prudent growth, invest in technology and cybersecurity, pursue strategic opportunities, and meet changing community needs.”
In July, the Fed proposed to amend Regulation MM to, among other things, eliminate certain dividend waiver requirements, reduce the burden associated with conversions from mutual-to-stock form, revise certain post-conversion restrictions, and eliminate the requirement that subsidiary holding companies of mutual holding companies obtain federal charters. The associations urged other federal regulators and state regulators to use the upcoming finalized version of the proposal as a template.
“Common standards would give mutual banks greater certainty regarding capital eligibility, facilitate investor understanding of the instruments, reduce unnecessary legal and transaction costs, and provide supervisors with a consistent basis for reviewing issuance and redemption,” ABA and ICBA said. “Just as importantly, a coordinated framework would help preserve the mutual charter as a viable long-term ownership model while supporting safety and soundness and the ability of mutual institutions to serve their communities.”









